Boiler InspectionsAnother Viewpoint

| May/June 1996

  • # Picture 01

  • # Picture 01

3040 160th Street Sumner, Iowa 50674

This article is intended as a response to Peter Bouley's article which appeared in the January/February issue of IMA, called 'Boiler Inspector: Friend of Foe?'

First off I'd like to say I've been a steam engine owner and operator for about 25 years and have owned various engines, currently owning five traction engines. I'd also say I'm not a boiler inspector hater and don't want to convey that through this article. During the years that Iowa had state inspections on hobby boilers I had a very good relationship, and still do, with the inspection department in Des Moines. I understood they had a job to do and were merely trying to do it. By the way, hobby boilers in the state of Iowa have been exempt from state or federal inspections since 1988.

One of the big things that concerns me with articles such as Mr. Bouley's is that some engine owners or operators read it and get the wrong idea. By this I mean that they may think that because their boiler is state inspected the state will share in the liability should an accident take place. We in the steam fraternity must never be lulled into a sense of false security by this. We as hobbyists must educate ourselves as to the safe operation of these engines in public because we are solely responsible for this, not the state or federal government.

Let me play the 'devil's advocate' here for a moment if I might. Let's take the worst case scenario and I pray this never happens: I've just gotten my 1912 Case engine state inspected and it passed with flying colors. So with my inspection certificate proudly tucked in my back pocket, I load the old girl up and head for the local show for a weekend of fun. During the parade the feed water pipe going into the side of the boiler ruptures and several people get scalded! Lawyers are called and litigation ensues. Now, if anyone thinks that because that engine had been certified, the state will step forward and share in the responsibility, they are 100% wrong. I'm afraid these inspectors would tuck their tails between their legs and head for the best defense lawyer money could buy. I always noted with a certain amount of amusement, on the bottom of my inspection certificate it always stated 'no defects noted at time of inspection.' I think this says it all in a nut-shell!

Another point that Mr. Bouley tries to get across that 'steams' me a little is his statement that 'The original thought at the time your tractor was built was to figure a life expectancy of 15-20 years tops! Today's boilers will last three or four times that long.' I question where he gets his information. In the first place, I seriously doubt if Mr. Bouley was included in the designing or construction of any of these boilers, around the turn of the century, so how could he possibly know how long they were intended to last? Secondly, if this were the case, I think that it's remarkable then that I have an Advance traction engine in my shed that just celebrated its 106th birthday. Up until the time of hobby boiler exemption, it was state certified to carry 100 psi working pressure year after year from the time it was restored in the 1960s. And for Mr. Bouley's information, this engine has a single row of rivets on the longitudinal seam. I was told by one of the last inspectors to look at it that he thought it was one of the nicest boilers he had seen, and I'm sure there are plenty of other hobbyists out there who can relate similar instances.


Farm Collector April 16Farm Collector is a monthly magazine focusing on antique tractors and all kinds of antique farm equipment. If it's old and from the farm, we're interested in it!

Save Even More Money with our SQUARE-DEAL Plan!

Pay now with a credit card and take advantage of our SQUARE-DEAL automatic renewal savings plan. You'll get 12 issues of Farm Collector for only $24.95 (USA only).

Or, Bill Me Later and send me one year of Farm Collector for just $29.95.

Facebook Pinterest YouTube